Todd J. Schuster

March 9, 1964 - August 13, 2019

Age 55, of Lima, NY, formerly of Warsaw, passed away peacefully on August 13, 2019 at Highland Hospital in Rochester.

He was born March 9, 1964 in Warsaw, son of Gary Schuster of Gainesville, NY and the late Carol Jorgensen Schuster. Todd was employed for many years as a cattle breeder for Paddock’s Breeding Service in Warsaw. In earlier years he worked on several area dairy farms.

Todd was an outdoorsman who enjoyed hunting and fishing. Above all else, he was devoted to his wife of nearly twenty-two years, Karen. Todd loved spending time with his family, especially his grandsons.

Surviving along with his father are his wife, Karen Warfle Schuster whom he married on October 18, 1997; his children, Jessica Morillo of Rochester and her former husband, Darwin Morillo, Nicole (Clint) O’Brien of Warsaw, Luke Paddock of Rochester, Joseph Paddock of College Station, Texas; grandsons, Jaxon Morillo, Joshua Morillo, Jameson O’Brien; his brother, Jeff Schuster of Geneseo; sister-in-law, Donna Schuster of Geneseo; brothers-in-law, Brian (Carol) Warfle of Wind Gap, Penn., Eugene Warfle of Vestal, NY; nieces and nephews, Danielle Schuster, Krista, Alexis, Alex, Jeffrey and Heather Warfle, Courtney Kincaid.

Friends may call Friday, August 16 from 3 – 7 PM at Robinson & Hackemer Funeral Home, 246 N. Main St., Warsaw. Todd’s funeral service will be held Saturday, August 17 at 11 AM at the Valley Chapel Free Methodist Church, Route 19 South, Warsaw. Burial will be in Maple Grove Cemetery, Gainesville. In lieu of flowers, memorials may be made to the Grace Life Church, 275 E. Main St., Avon, NY 14414.

Important Dates

August 16, 2019 : Calling hours for Todd J. Schuster - 3:00 PM to 7:00 PM

August 17, 2019 : Funeral service for Todd J. Schuster at the Valley Chapel Free Methodist Church - 11:00 AM

Sign Todd J. Schuster's Guest Book



To prevent SPAM, please type the word below:

Aug 16.19 from Gary Wallace:

We regret will be unable to attend calling hours/services for Todd, but he and his family are in our thoughts today.  We are donating to the American Cancer Society in hi memory. —Gary Wallace, Karen Lenney & Dorian Lenney-Wallace

Aug 15.19 from Lillian Rozanski:

so very sorry to hear about Todd. I’m sure he had a good life with his family. He was too young to leave this world. He will now be with his mom and grandma.











Aug 15.19 from Tim Wilcox:

Prayers to the entire family, Todd had a wonderful heart.

Aug 14.19 from John Oakes:

The old crew from Silver springs has lost another. We weren’t all the same age but we are all friends and Todd and Jeff were always in front of Dels at lunch time with the rest of us in the summer figuring out what we could get before going back to the ball field. Rest in Peace Todd. Only the good die young.